Every time I see their expressions in this scene, this is what I imagine:
Riario: What is that? What is she–? That is more than sin. That is just wrong.
Lucrezia: Huh. Okay, sure, I’ll try anything once.
Leo: Oh that? Zo and I did that twice in Pisa only there were three women, two pheasants and a goat.
Riario: How would that work with a goat?
Lucrezia: That’s really an interesting position.
Leo: It was fun. Zo pulled his back out. He still complains about it when it rains.
Riario: But… a goat?
Lucrezia: I could totally do that. I’m bendy.
Leo: I’d better make a note to remind Zo it’s going to rain tomorrow.
Lorenzo: Blah blah blah, welcome our esteemed guest, he’s a snake.
Riario: Quiet, man! Where can I find a goat this time of night?
Leo: Heh, got him.
100% canon. “Quiet, man! Where can i find a goat this time of night”, omg xD
They always make perfect expressions.